New Jersey Appellate Division Decision – Involuntary Medication for Competency Restoration in Criminal Law

On April 8, 2024, the New Jersey Appellate Division decided State of New Jersey v. J.H.P., 478 N.J. Super. 262 (App. Div. 2024), a significant case concerning the involuntary administration of medication to restore a defendant’s competency to stand trial. The Appellate Division reversed the lower court’s decision, setting an important precedent in cases where mental health and criminal law intersect.

Facts and Procedural History: Involuntary Medication for Competency Restoration

The case began with J.H.P. facing serious criminal charges, including second-degree burglary, aggravated arson, aggravated assault, and hindering apprehension. On January 12, 2020, the defendant J.H.P. allegedly set fire to a six-story apartment building, which was under construction in Bound Brook, causing $50 million in property damage and injuring a firefighter.

J.H.P. was detained pretrial for over two years before being transferred to a forensic facility due to concerns about his mental health. Multiple evaluations were conducted, diagnosing him with schizophrenia and deeming him incompetent to stand trial. The State sought a court order for involuntary medication for competency restoration, arguing that medicating J.H.P. was necessary to proceed with the trial.

Legal Issue: Involuntary Medication to Restore Competency

The primary legal issue in this case was whether the State could involuntarily medicate J.H.P. to attempt to restore his competency for trial. The Law Division initially ruled in favor of the State, applying the four-part test established by the U.S. Supreme Court in Sell v. United States, 539 U.S. 166 (2003), as applied by the Appellate Division in State v. R.G., 460 N.J. Super. 416 (App. Div. 2019). The Sell test permits involuntary medication in limited circumstances, such as when it is medically appropriate, unlikely to produce side effects that would interfere with the trial, and necessary to further important government interests.

Appellate Division’s Holding on Involuntary Medication for Competency Restoration

On appeal, the New Jersey Appellate Division reversed the lower court’s decision. The Appellate Division found that the State failed to satisfy the second prong of the Sell test because it did not demonstrate by clear and convincing evidence that it was substantially unlikely that the side effects of the antipsychotic mediation would interfere with the defendant’s ability to assist his attorney and the presentation of his defense. The Appellate Division also found that the State had not sufficiently proven that involuntary medication would significantly further its interest in restoring J.H.P.’s competency to stand trial. 

Reasoning: Involuntary Medication and Constitutional Rights

The Appellate Division court emphasized the need to protect constitutional rights, particularly the right to refuse unwanted medical treatment. The Appellate Division noted that involuntary medication should be used sparingly and only when absolutely necessary. In this case, the court determined that alternative treatments, such as competency restoration programs, had not been fully exhausted, making involuntary medication premature.

Conclusion: Key Takeaways on Involuntary Medication for Competency Restoration

The New Jersey Appellate Division’s decision in State of New Jersey v. J.H.P. highlights the critical balance courts must strike between protecting public safety and upholding an individual’s right to refuse medical treatment. The ruling underscores the importance of clear and convincing evidence before courts can order involuntary medication for competency restoration. This case serves as a reminder of the high standards required to justify such an order and the significant constitutional protections afforded to defendants in criminal cases.

Criminal law is complicated and constantly changing. If you are facing criminal charges, you should immediately contact our team of experienced former prosecutors to schedule a free case review with one of our expert criminal defense attorneys. A complete understanding of criminal law by your attorney is crucial to your defense. Your rights and freedoms are in jeopardy, and you owe it to yourself to act. We are available to provide immediate assistance and further counsel on your case at 862-315-7929.

No aspect of this attorney advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey.